Review Guidelines

A double-blind review is applied. Once a manuscript passes the initial checks, it will be assigned to at least two independent experts for peer-review. 
Reviewers can log in the peer-review system to download papers to be reviewed, upload review reports and check the list of review works.

The criteria for peer-review are as follows:
-The title, content and information are within the scope of the journal.
-The structure is complete and rigorous.
-The writing is easy to comprehend without distractions and deviations.
-The analytical and statistical methods are appropriate and relevant to the study. 
-The findings and conclusions are adequately supported by the data.
-The references adequately represent the data and interpretations are up to date without missing on key citable information.